Another predicable song for Melanie and as usual she sings the hell out of it.

Judges Comments

LA Reid: It’s predictable but America chose the song. I did not feel your usual passion.

Nicole Scherzinger: I love that America chose that song for you. You have your own power and strength up there.

Paula Abdul: Your voice is impeccable.

Simon Cowell: It wasn’t karaoke. That is called putting your stamp on the song.