We have got to agree with LA about the song choice. It is a bit predictable but non-the-less Melanie smashed it! It is the type of song she has for breakfast, lunch and dinner. She has the voice to deliver this type of song effortlessly and doesn’t Simon just know it.

Judges Comments

LA Reid: That was safe, but amazing.

Nicole Scherzinger: You gave me goosebumps.

Paula Abdul: This worked.

Simon Cowell: Give this girl some credit LA, she just sang that incredibly.