Last week they sang his praises, but a week is a long time on American Idol . This is what they made of his performance this week:

Randy Jackson: It was kind of half-half thing, but your still one of the greatest singer here.
Jennifer Lopez: You sing so great! It was beautiful, but it was a little no for you.
Steven Tyler: I don’t know that song of Billy Joel, but what you did, you sang your life into it.

Check out his performance below: