We had Colton down as a rocker, but after two weeks of love songs from the man with the tall hair, he is looking more like a lover.

This is what the judges made of his performance:

Randy Jackson: Song doesn’t matter because you performed it dope!

Jennifer Lopez: I love the beginning of it, I thought you deliver that well. Colton is a lover.

Steven Tyler: It was a wrong song choice for your voice and your passion.

Check out his performance below: