This was a perfect song choice for Josh and he sang it beautifully.

Judges Comments

LA Reid: That lacked excitement for me. Look ahead on where you can go.

Nicole Scherzinger: That was like a beautiful prayer.

Paula Abdul: LA how can you even say that? (Crying) I’ve never seen a contestant quite like you Josh.

Simon Cowell: I have to agree with Paula. You did what we knew you should do.