There is no doubt in our minds that Melanie is one of the best vocalists in the competition this year. We always look forward to her performance each week, because it always has the wow factor, but this week although the performance was good, we felt it lacked the wow factor – may be it was simply a tough song for anyone to sing except for MJ himself.

Judges Comments

LA Reid: I forgot that we were in a competition and I thought we were in a Melanie concert.

Nicole Scherzinger: One of the best performances of the season.

Paula Abdul: You are gorgeous up there.

Simon Cowell: You were amazing.